5 GTA men accused of kidnapping, attempted murder at Orillia gas station appear headed for trial
Five men from the Greater Toronto Area are headed for trial after provincial police discovered a bound and beaten Mississauga man inside an abandoned Orillia gas station on Sept. 27, 2025. The accused face charges of attempted murder and kidnapping, according to court records.
Why are these GTA men facing trial in Orillia?
Surjit Singh Bains, Manraj Mann, Dwayne Pennant, Baltej Sandhu, and Gergy Gorburn were arrested inside a building at Colborne Street and Peter Street South. Provincial police reported that investigators responded to reports of a suspicious vehicle and individuals wearing masks near the abandoned building.
The group faces multiple charges, including attempted murder, kidnapping, breaking and entering, and forcible confinement. Police also filed weapons counts and charges for uttering death threats. The victim, a Mississauga man, was taken to a hospital with serious injuries, according to police.
What is the current legal status of the accused?
Court records show varying bail outcomes for the five men. Gergy Gorburn, 51, was denied bail in December due to a lengthy criminal record involving breaking and entering and assaults. Dwayne Pennant was released in November on a $125,000 pledge but is currently incarcerated after allegedly breaching release conditions in Brampton this May.
Surjit Singh Bains, 63, spent more than two months in custody before his release. A publication ban currently prevents the disclosure of evidence from bail hearings and the identity of the victim.
When will the trial take place and what happens next?
The accused are scheduled for virtual court appearances in July. Trial dates are set for three weeks spanning from December through the end of March. Bains has already elected to be tried by a judge alone, while the other four men have not yet made their election.
Legal proceedings may focus on the evidence gathered at the Colborne Street scene. A possible next step could involve the remaining defendants deciding whether to proceed with a judge or a jury as the December start date approaches.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who are the men charged in the Orillia gas station incident?
The accused are Surjit Singh Bains, Manraj Mann, Dwayne Pennant, Baltej Sandhu, and Gergy Gorburn, hailing from Woodbridge, Brampton, and Mississauga.
What specific charges do the five men face?
They are charged with attempted murder, kidnapping, breaking and entering, forcible confinement, weapons counts, and uttering death threats.
Where did the crime occur?
The incident took place inside an abandoned gas station located at Colborne Street and Peter Street South in downtown Orillia, Ontario.
Do you believe strict bail conditions are effective in high-profile kidnapping cases?