7 Best Joker Comics of All Time, Ranked (& “The Killing Joke” Isn’t #1)
For over 80 years, the Joker has haunted Gotham City and captivated audiences as the iconic foil to Batman. His enduring appeal lies not just in his villainy, but in the complex stories that explore different facets of his character – sometimes humorous, sometimes terrifying, and almost always a commentary on society. While many stories define the Clown Prince of Crime, a recent look identifies seven of the best Joker tales in comic book history, deliberately excluding the well-known “The Killing Joke.”
The Joker’s Enduring Legacy
The Joker’s presence in Batman lore is foundational. His very first appearance in Batman #1 (1940) was a landmark moment, not only introducing the villain alongside Catwoman, but also influencing the implementation of Batman’s “no killing” rule following public reaction to the hero’s actions in that issue. The Joker immediately established his signature style: announcing crimes in advance, taunting authorities, and leaving his calling card at the scene. Elements of this early portrayal even resonate in modern interpretations, such as those seen in Christopher Nolan’s The Dark Knight.
A Villain’s Many Faces
The Joker’s stories often delve into the “what ifs” of his character. Batman: White Knight presents a compelling scenario: what if the Joker were cured of his madness? In this eight-issue series, Jack Napier, now sane, becomes a politician attempting to reform Gotham and expose Batman as the true threat. However, the story avoids a simple good-versus-evil dynamic, exploring themes of economic inequality, police reform, and the codependency between Batman and the Joker.
Other notable stories showcase the Joker’s range. “The Laughing Fish” from Detective Comics #475 (1978) offers a bizarre and hilarious take on the villain, while “Joker’s Millions” in Detective Comics #180 sees him grappling with the mundane challenge of IRS taxes after inheriting a fortune. These stories highlight the Joker’s ego and his ability to disrupt even the most ordinary aspects of life.
Escalation and Consequences
More recent stories, like Batman: Endgame, demonstrate a darker, more violent side of the Joker. This storyline involves the release of a deadly pathogen, attacks on key figures like Commissioner Gordon, and a desperate escalation of chaos. The Joker’s actions push Batman to seek help from even questionable allies, like the Court of Owls, and ultimately lead to a destructive confrontation.
Perhaps the most significant origin story, however, remains Detective Comics #168. This issue details the transformation of a failed criminal, the Red Hood, into the Joker after a fall into a chemical vat. While the Joker’s origins have been retold and revised over the years, this story remains a foundational element of his character.
Finally, Gotham Central #12-15 (“Soft Targets”) presents a particularly chilling portrayal of the Joker, depicting a series of escalating attacks, including the assassination of the mayor, and a relentless torment of the Gotham City police. This story is noted for its realistic and intense depiction of chaos and its consequences.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes the Joker such a compelling villain?
The Joker’s appeal stems from his unpredictable nature, his complex motivations, and his ability to serve as a dark mirror to Batman, often challenging the hero’s principles and methods.
Which Joker story is considered his first origin story?
Detective Comics #168 (1951) is credited with providing the Joker’s first origin story, detailing his transformation from the Red Hood after falling into a vat of chemicals.
Does the Joker ever truly “win” in these stories?
While the Joker often causes immense chaos and suffering, the stories examined here generally conclude with his defeat or capture, though he frequently vows to escape and continue his reign of terror.
Considering the diverse portrayals of the Joker across these stories, what do you think is the most essential element that defines this iconic villain?