Former Mob Hitman and NJ Councilman John Alite Arrested for Extortion and Loansharking
John Alite, a 63-year-old Englishtown councilman and former mob hitman, was arrested Friday in New Jersey on charges of extortion, loansharking, and terroristic threats. According to prosecutors, Alite used his company, Straightened-Out Entertainment Inc., to illegally obtain money through threats of violence, echoing criminal patterns from his youth.
Alite appeared in court Saturday and was released. He is scheduled to return for a detention hearing this Wednesday. His attorney, Douglas Anton, stated via email that he will not comment on the case before the next court date.
What are the charges against John Alite?
Alite faces multiple counts of loansharking, extortion, corporate misconduct, and terroristic threats. Prosecutors allege he provided loans at exorbitant rates and then used threats of violence to collect the debts.
According to a release from prosecutors, Alite utilized his corporation, Straightened-Out Entertainment Inc., to carry out these crimes. They claim he illegally obtained money and property from victims through violence.
What evidence did New Jersey State Police find?
An officer with the New Jersey State Police, which serves as an investigative arm of the attorney general’s office, stated in court papers that the weapons found at Alite’s residence were likely intended for debt collection.
Authorities found one baseball bat stored near the front door and five others in a kitchen storage bench. Court papers indicate Alite threatened one borrower, telling the individual he would strike him across the head with a baseball bat if demands weren’t met.
The court documents also state that Alite bragged about previously attempting to “gut” people like “fish.”
How does this relate to Alite’s criminal past?
Prosecutors say Alite’s current alleged actions reflect his 2009 testimony during the trial of John “Junior” Gotti. That trial ultimately ended with a deadlocked jury.

During that Manhattan federal court proceeding, Alite testified that he killed a childhood friend. He stated he committed the murder to gain respect from other mobsters.
What happens next in the legal process?
Alite’s legal status may change following his scheduled detention hearing on Wednesday. A judge could determine whether he remains released or must be detained pending trial.
If the charges are proven in court, Alite may face significant penalties for the extortion and loansharking counts. The outcome likely depends on the evidence provided by the New Jersey State Police and the testimony of the victims.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is John Alite’s current professional role?
Alite was sworn in early last year as a councilman in the borough of Englishtown, New Jersey.
What weapons were found during the search of Alite’s home?
Authorities found six baseball bats, an expandable baton, metal knuckles, and about two dozen knives, including switchblades.
Who did John Alite testify against in the past?
Alite testified against John “Junior” Gotti in a 2009 trial.
Do you believe a person’s criminal history should disqualify them from holding local government office?