Former San Antonio Officer Named Benavides Police Chief After Feces Sandwich Scandal
Matthew Luckhurst, a former San Antonio Police Department officer fired for allegedly feeding a sandwich containing dog feces to a homeless person in 2016, has been appointed as the police chief for the Benavides Police Department. According to the city’s website, Luckhurst has served with the department since January 2025.
The Benavides Police Department maintains that Luckhurst’s tenure with the agency, which began in April 2023, has been exemplary with no complaints or issues reported prior to his promotion to chief.
The Path to Appointment
The Benavides Police Department stated that the hiring of Luckhurst reflects a departmental commitment to providing individuals with a second chance. According to an official statement, the agency conducted a thorough background check before swearing him in as a peace officer, ensuring all aspects of his professional history were carefully considered.
Luckhurst’s previous career in San Antonio ended in an indefinite suspension. He was accused of placing dog feces on bread in a styrofoam container and delivering it to a homeless individual in May 2016. The Benavides Police Department did not immediately respond to requests for comment regarding the specific details of his vetting process.
Samantha Carter notes that the appointment underscores a significant divide in how small-town agencies and large metropolitan departments assess officer eligibility. While the San Antonio Police Department utilized indefinite suspension as a disciplinary measure for the 2016 incident, Benavides officials are prioritizing a restorative approach, weighing his recent performance record against past allegations.
What May Happen Next
As Luckhurst transitions into his leadership role, the department may face increased public scrutiny regarding its hiring standards. Observers could expect the city to face inquiries about how it balances past disciplinary records against current performance metrics. If community concerns persist, the city may be forced to provide further transparency regarding the specific criteria used during the hiring and promotion process.
Frequently Asked Questions
When did Matthew Luckhurst begin his role with the Benavides Police Department?
According to the city’s website, Luckhurst joined the department in April 2023 and has served as police chief since January 2025.
Why was Luckhurst suspended from his previous department?
Luckhurst was indefinitely suspended from the San Antonio Police Department for allegedly giving a homeless person a sandwich containing dog feces in May 2016.
How has the Benavides Police Department addressed concerns regarding his hiring?
The department stated that the hiring reflects a commitment to second chances and noted that a thorough background check was conducted to consider all aspects of his history.
How should small-town police departments balance the need for second chances with the requirement for public trust in leadership?