Hilary Duff: Luck… or Something Album Review

Hilary Duff’s latest album, luck…, marks a distinct shift from her earlier collaborations, notably those with Zedd in the mid-2010s. The new work leans more toward the sound of artists like Carly Rae Jepsen, a former collaborator, characterized by a bright and upbeat vocal style. The album’s musical foundation consists of synths and acoustic pop, enhanced with drum fills and strings, creating a softer backdrop for Duff’s vocals.

A New Creative Direction

This is the first album where Duff receives credit as a co-writer on every song, suggesting a greater level of creative control. However, the lyrics demonstrate a work in progress, with Duff experimenting with different voices – from meticulous wordplay to casual, conversational tones. Some lyrical choices, like the line “You calling me batshit’s the fastest antibiotic/For thinking you’re different this time,” are described as clunky, while others remain ambiguous, such as the meaning behind the “holey T-shirt” in “Adult Size Medium.”

Despite these inconsistencies, moments of clarity emerge, reminiscent of the qualities that made pop stars relatable. “Tell Me That Won’t Happen,” despite its upbeat sound, explores existential dread with the hook, “I’m worried that I’ve felt everything I’ll ever feel.” Similarly, “Roommates” uses humour to address potential vulnerability, acknowledging the fear of rejection.

Exploring Personal and Societal Themes

The album delves into complex themes, particularly on the track “Mature.” This song examines the dynamic between a younger woman and an older man, a relationship Duff herself experienced beginning at age 16 with a musician nearly a decade her senior. This exploration occurs within the context of the post-#MeToo era, where age-gap relationships are being re-evaluated. A 2021 essay by Tavi Gevinson highlighted the power imbalance inherent in such dynamics, stating, “If you can still be considered ‘mature for your age,’ you are not an older person’s equal.”

The Relatable Pop Star

Duff doesn’t shy away from acknowledging the complexities of life, even in moments intended as retrospective. The album closer, “Adult Size Medium,” lists a series of experiences – “Try-hards, icons, Sunday mornings, Super Bowls, turn ons, tampons, edibles, and booty calls” – without attempting to create a polished narrative. She expresses a sense of ambivalence, admitting, “I remember it all/And I remember nothing,” reflecting the often-forgotten moments that comprise a life.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the overall sound of luck…?

The album’s sound is described as less influenced by Zedd and more akin to Carly Rae Jepsen, featuring chirpy synths, acoustic pop, and softer instrumentation.

Is Duff solely responsible for the lyrics on this album?

This is the first album where Duff is credited as a co-writer on every song, but the lyrics show her experimenting with different styles and voices, resulting in both strong and weaker lines.

What themes does the album explore?

The album touches on themes of aging, vulnerability, relationships, and the complexities of navigating life, particularly in the context of past experiences and societal shifts like the #MeToo movement.

How often do you find yourself reflecting on the past with a mix of clarity and forgetfulness?