How An X-Files Episode Created TV’s Scariest Villain
For fans of The X-Files, the shadowy figure known as the Cigarette Smoking Man is instantly recognizable as the series’ primary antagonist. However, the evolution of this iconic villain from a silent presence to a central force was a gradual one, solidified in the Season 2 episode “One Breath.” What many assume was a planned arc from the beginning was, in fact, a development born from opportunity and a surprising performance.
The Silent Threat
William B. Davis first appeared in the very first episode of The X-Files, but notably, he didn’t speak. He lurked in the background during scenes involving Scully and her FBI superiors, immediately establishing an air of mystery and intrigue. This initial portrayal was not intended to be a starring role; Davis had previously appeared in the show as a CIA agent in “Young At Heart,” suggesting he was simply being used as an extra.
Evil Finds Its Voice
The character’s voice was first heard in the Season 1 episode “Tooms,” marking a turning point in his on-screen presence. However, it was the script for “One Breath” that presented the biggest challenge and opportunity for Davis. Director Robert Goodwin initially expressed concern, as the episode demanded more from Davis than he had previously delivered.
Episode co-writer Glen Morgan successfully convinced Goodwin that Davis, who was also a drama teacher, possessed the acting ability to handle the expanded role. Goodwin was ultimately impressed by Davis’ performance, a pivotal moment in the show’s history.
The Truth Is In Here
“One Breath” is crucial because it firmly established the Cigarette Smoking Man as the ultimate villain, a manipulator willing to endanger the lives of Mulder and Scully. The episode centers around Mulder’s pursuit of the man responsible for Scully’s abduction and subsequent coma. He confronts the Cigarette Smoking Man at his home, holding him at gunpoint.
In a chilling display of power, the Cigarette Smoking Man remains remarkably calm, revealing that he allowed Scully’s return simply because he finds the agents “interesting.” He asserts his control over their fates, claiming he will always win because Mulder won’t kill the one person who possesses the truth. Mulder, defeated, leaves empty-handed.
Mulder’s Dark Reflection
This scene, though brief, is profoundly impactful. It positions the Cigarette Smoking Man not merely as an enemy, but as a mirror image of Mulder himself – someone driven by a relentless pursuit of truth, willing to go to any lengths to protect it. William B. Davis’ performance, as noted by director Robert Goodwin, imbues the character with both menace and a surprising vulnerability, making him a uniquely dangerous threat.
Following “One Breath,” the Cigarette Smoking Man became a recurring figure throughout The X-Files, appearing in the series finale, the first movie, and even the show’s revival. This expanded role was directly attributable to William B. Davis’ compelling performance in this pivotal episode.
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the Cigarette Smoking Man’s initial role in The X-Files?
He initially appeared as a silent, unnamed figure in the background of scenes, creating an air of mystery.
In which episode did the Cigarette Smoking Man first speak?
He first spoke in the Season 1 episode “Tooms.”
Why was the director of “One Breath” initially concerned about William B. Davis’ performance?
The script for “One Breath” gave Davis a much larger role than he had previously had, and there were concerns he might not be able to handle it.
Considering the impact of “One Breath,” and the character’s subsequent prominence, do you think the initial, understated approach to the Cigarette Smoking Man ultimately enhanced his effectiveness as a villain?