Murder trial begins for man accused of ‘decapitating and dismembering’ Christchurch man Richard Leman

A New Zealand trial is underway concerning the death of Richard Leman, whose body was discovered dismembered and concealed in a vehicle. Michael Scott Rodger is accused of murder, and the case, expected to last four weeks, will involve testimony from over 30 witnesses.

Details of the Allegation

The Crown alleges that the events leading to Leman’s death began on April 11, 2023. Leman, described as having a “chaotic lifestyle” involving methamphetamine use and potential gang connections, was reportedly facing financial difficulties and concerns about breaching a protection order related to his children.

A Night of Fatal Encounters

On the evening of April 11th, Leman met with Sara Plimmer and Morgan Grant – also known as Molly. CCTV footage places Leman at a Rangiora Burger King drive-through around 9:17 PM. He then drove to Grant’s home, bringing takeaways for both women. The prosecution asserts that Grant then invited Rodger to the residence, knowing Leman was present.

The Shooting and Aftermath

According to the Crown’s case, an argument ensued between Rodger and Leman, culminating in Rodger allegedly shooting Leman twice – once in the leg and fatally in the chest. No immediate medical assistance was provided. Following the shooting, Rodger is accused of threatening Plimmer and Grant, looting Leman of cash and drugs, and then dismembering the body.

Did You Know? The victim’s torso was discovered wrapped in plastic in the boot of his own car six days after his death.

Evidence and Forensic Findings

Police discovered Leman’s torso in the boot of his car at a vacant property. His head and limbs were not found. A hatchet discovered with the remains reportedly contained Leman’s blood and tissue, suggesting its use in the dismemberment. Rodger allegedly spent time at Grant’s home in the days following the death, and Grant is accused of attempting to clean the house and dispose of the vehicle.

The defence’s Stance

The defence, led by Pip Hall KC, argues that the evidence presented by the Crown is unreliable and that Rodger is not guilty. Hall asserts that the accounts of Plimmer and Grant are questionable and potentially motivated by self-preservation or other factors. He claims the Crown’s narrative lacks a solid foundation.

Expert Insight: The defence’s strategy centers on discrediting the eyewitness testimony, a common tactic in cases where direct physical evidence is limited or contested. Successfully casting doubt on the reliability of these witnesses could be crucial to securing an acquittal.

Frequently Asked Questions

What was Richard Leman involved in prior to his death?

According to the prosecution, Leman was involved in the consumption and supply of methamphetamine, which may have led to financial problems and attracted the attention of gangs. He was also reportedly facing difficulties with his ex-partner and concerns about breaching a protection order.

What did the prosecution say about the events at Morgan Grant’s home?

The prosecution alleges that Morgan Grant invited Michael Rodger to her home knowing Richard Leman was there, leading to an argument and the shooting of Leman by Rodger.

What is the defence’s primary argument?

The defence argues that the evidence presented by the Crown is unreliable and that the accounts of Sara Plimmer and Molly Grant are questionable, asserting that Michael Rodger did not shoot Richard Leman.

As the trial progresses, will the jury be able to reconcile the conflicting accounts and determine the truth behind the events of April 11th?