Neil Gaiman claims sexual assault allegations are result of ‘smear campaign’

Author Neil Gaiman, 65, has publicly addressed allegations of sexual misconduct for the first time in nearly a year, asserting that the claims made against him are “completely and simply untrue.” The author, known for works like American Gods and The Ocean at the End of the Lane, characterized the accusations as part of a “smear campaign.”

The Allegations

The accusations of sexual abuse and coercive behavior first surfaced in a July 2024 podcast by Tortoise Media. A subsequent investigation by New York Magazine followed in January 2025, prompting a statement from Gaiman maintaining he had “never engaged in nonconsensual sexual activity with anyone.”

Did You Know? Nine women have come forward with accusations against Neil Gaiman, including Scarlett Pavlovich, who previously worked as a nanny for Gaiman and his wife, Amanda Palmer.

Professional Repercussions

The allegations have already begun to impact Gaiman’s professional life. Dark Horse, a comic publisher, has ended its relationship with him. DC Comics, the publisher of Sandman, has postponed a planned reprint of his work. A stage adaptation of his children’s book, Coraline, was cancelled a year ago following the initial claims.

Gaiman’s Response

In a post on his Facebook author page, Gaiman stated he possesses “emails, text messages and video evidence” that contradict the allegations. He expressed disappointment with the reporting, claiming it functioned as an “echo chamber” that dismissed available evidence. Gaiman believes that some outlets prioritized sensationalism and “clicks on headlines” over factual accuracy.

Expert Insight: Accusations of this nature often trigger immediate and significant consequences for those involved, even before formal investigations conclude. The decisions by Dark Horse and DC Comics demonstrate the potential for reputational and financial damage that can accompany such allegations, regardless of their ultimate veracity.

Despite the ongoing controversy, Gaiman revealed he has resumed writing and is nearing completion of a new novel. He expressed gratitude to those who continue to support his work and believe in his innocence.

What Could Happen Next

further legal action could be taken by either party. A possible next step could involve the release of the evidence Gaiman claims to possess. The outcome of the divorce proceedings involving Gaiman and Amanda Palmer could also influence public perception. Analysts expect continued scrutiny of the situation from both the media and Gaiman’s fanbase.

Frequently Asked Questions

What was Neil Gaiman’s initial response to the allegations?

In January 2025, Gaiman stated he had “never engaged in nonconsensual sexual activity with anyone. Ever” following the New York Magazine investigation.

Which publishers have taken action in response to the allegations?

Dark Horse has dropped Gaiman, and DC Comics has pulled a planned reprint of his work.

What is Gaiman currently working on?

Gaiman revealed he is close to finishing a new novel.

How will the evolving landscape of media accountability impact similar situations in the future?

Neil Gaiman claims sexual assault allegations are result of ‘smear campaign’ | Neil Gaiman