Storie al Bivio di Sera: Monica Setta e la Pedagogia dei Sentimenti
Monica Setta’s Rai2 program “Storie al bivio di sera” is facing criticism for prioritizing emotional appeal over critical interviewing, according to critic Aldo Grasso. In a review dated June 24, 2026, Grasso argues the show exemplifies a broader trend in generalist television where sentimentalism and confession replace complexity and storytelling.
The program recently featured guests including Eva Grimaldi, Minister Andrea Abodi, and Dalila Di Lazzaro. Grasso claims that regardless of the guest, Setta employs a stylistic approach based on “emotional emphasis” to secure the affective participation of the audience.
Why is the interviewing style of “Storie al bivio di sera” being criticized?
Aldo Grasso describes Setta’s method as “caressing” and “consoling” rather than challenging. He asserts that the host avoids putting the guests’ narratives into question, opting instead to guide them along a pre-traced emotional path.
The critic suggests that empathy in the show has transformed into a form of “affectation” that may stifle spontaneity. He notes that the program avoids contrast, surprise, and ambiguity in favor of a “pedagogy of feelings.”
How does this reflect broader trends in generalist television?
According to Grasso, generalist TV has progressively substituted argumentation with emotion and storytelling with confession. He views “Storie al bivio di sera” as a primary example of this shift toward “sentimentaloide hyperbole.”
The review states that various themes—including pain, nostalgia, success, and rebirth—are treated with the same emotional intensity. Grasso claims this approach ensures every story is presented as “extraordinary” through the use of heavy adjectives and emotive pauses.
What could happen next for generalist TV formats?
The continued success of emotional-centric formats may lead other generalist networks to further reduce narrative complexity. This could result in a television landscape where “confession” becomes the standard mode of communication for public figures.
Future programs may likely lean further into the “pedagogy of feelings” described by Grasso, potentially marginalizing interview styles that rely on contrast or critical questioning.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who hosts the program “Storie al bivio di sera”?
The program on Rai2 is hosted by Monica Setta.
Which guests recently appeared on the show?
Guests included Eva Grimaldi, Dalila Di Lazzaro, and Minister Andrea Abodi.
What is the primary criticism of the show’s tone?
Aldo Grasso claims the show replaces complexity and argumentation with sentimentalism and emotional emphasis.
Do you prefer interviews that challenge their guests or those that provide emotional support?