Black Montreal Police Employees Fear Reprisals Amid Racism Probe
Black employees of the Montreal police force reported fears of reprisal and a reluctance to return to work in a June 14 letter to management. The alarm follows the dismantling of a patrol unit where two officers were suspended and 14 others reassigned over allegations of racist misconduct and hateful acts against Black and Arab citizens.
Why was the Montreal police patrol unit dismantled?
Police Chief Fady Dagher announced on June 12 that a series of investigations into racist misconduct led to the suspension of two officers and the reassignment of 14 others. According to Dagher, the investigation began in March after fellow officers provided information regarding “reprehensible behaviour.”
The allegations include reports that some officers cut the hair of racialized citizens to keep as “trophies.” Chief Dagher stated that two of the officers involved could face criminal charges as the investigation continues.
Why are Black employees afraid to go to work?
In a letter sent to deputy director Marc Charbonneau, a committee of Black employees claimed they have learned of efforts to identify whistleblowers within certain units. The group wrote that some staff members now “fear reprisals” and are reluctant to report for duty.
The employees asserted that “silence does not build trust” and urged the department to protect those who denounce disgraceful behaviour. They are calling for reporting mechanisms that are independent, credible, and safe from professional consequences.
What is the public and political reaction to the allegations?
Hundreds of residents rallied outside Station 39 in Montréal-Nord on Monday to protest police brutality and support the victims of the alleged misconduct. Civil rights groups and various politicians claim these issues are not new and require urgent intervention.
The Red Coalition, a civil rights advocacy group, shared the internal employee letter with The Canadian Press to highlight the systemic nature of the problem. These groups, along with several politicians, are currently calling on the Quebec government to launch an independent inquiry into the police force to restore public trust.
How is the city administration responding?
A spokesperson for Montreal Mayor Soraya Martinez Ferrada confirmed the mayor is aware of the employees’ letter. The mayor’s office stated she will organize a meeting as soon as possible to address the concerns.
The Montreal police department told The Canadian Press they intend to respond to the letter’s specific questions. Meanwhile, former officer André Gélinas, retired since 2019, told reporters he believes the system is working because the police chief held a public press conference at 10:30 p.m. to address the seriousness of the claims.
Comparison: Internal vs. External Accountability
| Current Police Approach | Demands from Employees/Groups |
|---|---|
| Internal whistleblower hotline | Independent, credible reporting mechanisms |
| Internal investigation by Chief Dagher | Independent government inquiry |
| Administrative reassignments | Fundamental change in organizational culture |
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is leading the investigation into the Montreal police?
Police Chief Fady Dagher is overseeing the current investigation, which began in March based on reports from within the force.
What specific misconduct was alleged?
Allegations include racism, hateful acts toward Black and Arab people during police stops, and the cutting of citizens’ hair to be kept as trophies.
What are the Black employees demanding?
They are calling for the protection of whistleblowers and the strengthening of reporting mechanisms to ensure employees can report misconduct without fearing personal or professional reprisals.
Want to stay updated on police reform and civil rights issues?
Join the conversation in the comments below or subscribe to our newsletter for the latest verified reporting on urban justice.