Corbin Bleu, John Behlmann to join ‘The Great Gatsby’ Broadway cast
Broadway is gearing up for a cast change in its current production of The Great Gatsby, with Corbin Bleu and John Behlmann set to join the company beginning March 30th at the Broadway Theatre. These additions come as the musical continues its adaptation of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s iconic novel.
New Faces in West Egg
Corbin Bleu, known for his role in High School Musical, will take on the role of Nick Carraway. He previously performed the role in London’s West End in 2025. John Behlmann, recently appearing in Broadway productions of Smash, Shucked, and Tootsie, will portray Tom Buchanan.
The incoming actors will replace current cast members Michael Maliakel and Austin Colby, who will give their final performances as Nick and Tom on March 29th. Reeve Carney is slated to begin performances as Jay Gatsby on March 30th, alongside Bleu and Behlmann.
Shifting Roles and Existing Performances
This transition follows the conclusion of Jeremy Jordan’s run as Jay Gatsby on March 7th, with Ryan McCartan returning to the role from March 8th through March 29th. Eva Noblezada will begin performances as Daisy Buchanan on March 4th. Prior to Noblezada’s arrival, the role of Daisy will be shared by Traci Elaine Lee, Elena Ricardo, and Kyla Stone through March 2nd.
The Great Gatsby musical centres on the enigmatic millionaire Jay Gatsby and his pursuit of the married socialite Daisy Buchanan.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is currently playing Jay Gatsby?
Ryan McCartan will play Jay Gatsby from March 8th through March 29th, following Jeremy Jordan’s final performance on March 7th.
When do Corbin Bleu and John Behlmann begin their roles?
Corbin Bleu and John Behlmann will begin performing as Nick Carraway and Tom Buchanan, respectively, on March 30th.
Who will play Daisy Buchanan before Eva Noblezada joins the cast?
Through March 2nd, the role of Daisy Buchanan will be shared by Traci Elaine Lee, Elena Ricardo, and Kyla Stone.
What impact these casting changes will have on the show’s overall reception remains to be seen, but the production is clearly aiming to maintain momentum as it continues its Broadway run.