Hamnet deserved better at Golden Globes

The 83rd Golden Globes, held on January 12, sparked varied reactions, with Nikki Glaser returning as host and delivering a performance praised for its sharp wit. While some wins were celebrated, others prompted debate among observers.

A Night of Wins and Surprises

Nikki Glaser’s hosting was highlighted for its “biting, risque humour” that remained respectful. Specific jokes included comparisons of Sean Penn to a “sexy leather handbag,” observations about Leonardo DiCaprio’s dating life, and a playfully suggestive comment regarding Michael B. Jordan’s role in Sinners.

Stellan Skarsgärd received the award for Best Supporting Actor for his performance in Sentimental Value. His acceptance speech focused on the unique experience of cinema, emphasizing the shared connection felt by audiences in a darkened theater – the feeling of ‘sharing the pulse’ with others.

Teyana Taylor was recognized as Best Supporting Actress for One Battle After Another, though some felt Amy Madigan (Weapons) or Elle Fanning (Sentimental Value) were more deserving. Taylor’s portrayal of Perfidia, a revolutionary, was described as both “alluring and terrifying,” alongside Sean Penn’s character, Colonel Lockjaw.

Did You Know? One Battle After Another received four Golden Globes, the most of any film at the ceremony.

Differing Reactions to the Winners

One Battle After Another secured wins for Best Supporting Actress (Taylor), Best Screenplay, Best Director (Paul Thomas Anderson), and Best Picture in the Comedy/Musical category. Despite its critical success, one observer described the film as “highly-suspenseful” and “full of dry humour,” but ultimately a “harsh” portrayal where even well-intentioned characters exhibit flaws.

Bugonia, also a dark comedy, did not receive any awards. It was noted as potentially more fitting for the Comedy category due to its greater comedic elements, despite also featuring complex characters.

The Rise of Hamnet

While not yet released in Australia at the time of the Globes, Hamnet garnered significant attention, winning Best Actress for Jessie Buckley and Best Picture, Drama. The film, based on Maggie O’Farrell’s 2020 novel, explores the life of William Shakespeare (Paul Mescal), his wife Agnes (Buckley), and the impact of their son Hamnet’s death on Shakespeare’s creation of Hamlet.

Expert Insight: The focus on Agnes’s perspective in Hamnet represents a deliberate narrative choice, offering a fresh lens through which to examine a well-known historical figure and his most famous work. This approach could signal a broader trend in biographical dramas toward centering previously marginalized voices.

Buckley’s performance as Agnes was lauded as “captivating,” with some predicting an Oscar win. Mescal was praised for his portrayal of a grounded Shakespeare, and Noah Jupe’s performance as Hamnet was described as “heartwrenching.” Chloé Zhao’s direction was noted for its deliberate pacing and its depiction of the relationship between Agnes and William.

The film’s production design, including costumes and sets, was also highlighted, creating a contrast between the Shakespeares’ rural home and the urban environment of London. The use of steady camerawork was also praised as a refreshing departure from the “shaky-cam” often found in historical dramas like Train Dreams.

What’s Next?

With the awards season underway, Hamnet is likely to continue gaining recognition. A strong showing at the Oscars is a distinct possibility, given the praise Jessie Buckley has already received. One Battle After Another, despite mixed reactions, could also remain a contender in various categories. It’s possible that the Golden Globes results will influence voting patterns among awards bodies, potentially shifting momentum towards films like Hamnet that were not as heavily favored initially.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who hosted the 83rd Golden Globes?

Nikki Glaser hosted the 83rd Golden Globes, marking her second time hosting the ceremony.

Which film won Best Picture, Comedy/Musical?

One Battle After Another won Best Picture, Comedy/Musical.

Which film won Best Picture, Drama?

Hamnet won Best Picture, Drama.

Considering the critical acclaim surrounding films like Hamnet, do you think awards shows accurately reflect the quality of cinematic achievements?