New Approach: Sheriff’s Office designates deputy to focus on animal cruelty cases | News, Sports, Jobs
Chautauqua County has appointed Deputy Jim Andin as a dedicated officer to handle animal cruelty cases, according to Sheriff Jim Quattrone. The position, funded by the Chautauqua County Legislature in January, provides specialized training to investigate abuse involving cats, dogs, farm animals, and exotic pets.
Why does Chautauqua County need a dedicated animal cruelty deputy?
Sheriff Jim Quattrone stated that animal cruelty cases are complicated and require specialized training beyond the brief overview deputies receive at the Academy. Deputy Jim Andin will fill this role, focusing specifically on these investigations.
Andin works alongside a veterinary technician to assess whether animals are receiving proper medical treatment, food, water, and shelter. This partnership allows the Sheriff’s Office to conduct more thorough evaluations of potential abuse.
How does the Chautauqua County Humane Society support these efforts?
The Chautauqua County Humane Society serves as the county’s designated provider for housing and care. Executive Director Jane Babinsky said the organization is “honored” to partner with the Sheriff’s Office to help “innocent victims of abuse and neglect.”

The organization operates on donations and faces significant space constraints. Sheriff Quattrone noted that seizing a dozen or more animals at once can create a heavy burden on the facility.
Babinsky stated that the organization hopes to expand its building within the next three years. However, she admitted that space is likely to remain tight even after a potential expansion.
What is the link between animal abuse and human violence?
State Sen. George Borrello, R-Sunset Bay, emphasized the importance of prosecuting animal abusers during the Friday news conference. Borrello said while some abusers face financial constraints or mental illness, others “just have evil in their hearts.”
Borrello noted that many serial killers begin as animal abusers. Assemblyman Andrew Molitor, R-Westfield, added that studies show individuals who harm animals are more likely to commit acts of violence against people.
Borrello stated that holding people accountable for animal abuse now could help prevent further tragedies in the future.
What other safety measures has the county implemented?
James Feldmann, representing County Executive PJ Wendel, said the animal cruelty deputy is part of a broader trend of county safety investments. He listed several recent additions to county resources.
These include the addition of school resource officers, the creation of an unsolved cases unit, and the establishment of a re-entry hub for individuals released from jail. Feldmann described the new deputy as a significant step in protecting those who cannot protect themselves.
How to report animal abuse in Chautauqua County
Residents can report suspected abuse through the “Get involved” tab on the Chautauqua County Humane Society website. For non-emergencies, the Sheriff’s Office can be reached at 716-753-4231, while 911 should be used for emergencies.

Frequently Asked Questions
Which animals are covered under these investigations?
According to Sheriff Quattrone, investigations include cats, dogs, farm animals, and exotic pets.
When did the funding for the dedicated deputy begin?
The Chautauqua County Legislature officially began funding the position in January.
What challenges does the Humane Society currently face?
The organization relies on donations and struggles with a lack of available space when large numbers of animals are seized.
How should communities balance the cost of specialized law enforcement with the need for animal shelter expansions?