The Only Living Pickpocket in New York review – John Turturro steals this simple, charming tale

Noah Segan’s new film, The Only Living Pickpocket in New York, explores the tensions between past and present, depicting a world where older generations struggle to adapt to a rapidly changing digital landscape. The film, described as a 70s-era character-led thriller, centers on a protagonist who embodies a disappearing way of life.

A Dying Breed

The title itself references a Simon and Garfunkel song, immediately establishing a nostalgic tone. The film’s protagonist, Harry, is a pickpocket who prefers traditional methods, even as he occasionally encounters smartphones among his targets. He is portrayed by John Turturro, an actor whose recent roles haven’t offered the same substantial opportunities as this one.

Did You Know? The film runs for 88 minutes, maintaining a brisk pace reminiscent of classic thrillers.

A Familiar Character

Harry operates primarily in the New York City subway system, living in the Bronx but working in Manhattan. He sells his stolen goods to Ben, a pawnbroker and old friend, and dedicates his time to caring for his wife, who is unable to speak or move due to a degenerative disease. His life takes a dangerous turn when he steals from the wrong person – the son of a connected crime family.

Nostalgia and Performance

While the film’s themes of generational differences are sometimes overstated, the sincerity of its tribute to a bygone era is evident. The film benefits from a strong performance by Tatiana Maslany, who portrays Harry’s estranged daughter and delivers a powerfully emotional scene. Turturro, at 68, is described as looking remarkably well and bringing a likable quality to his morally ambiguous character.

Expert Insight: The film’s focus on a character clinging to outdated methods in a modern city highlights a common narrative tension – the struggle to find relevance and purpose in a world that increasingly values innovation and efficiency. This theme resonates with broader anxieties about technological displacement and the loss of traditional skills.

A Bittersweet Ending

The script occasionally relies on contrived explanations, and a last-minute cameo by an Oscar-winning actor feels somewhat jarring. However, the film ultimately delivers a satisfyingly bittersweet conclusion. It serves as an homage to New York City, a specific time period, the crime thriller genre, and the talent of John Turturro.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Harry’s profession?

Harry is a pickpocket who prides himself on using traditional methods, though he occasionally steals smartphones.

Who plays Harry’s daughter?

Tatiana Maslany plays Harry’s estranged daughter, delivering a performance described as bringing decades of anger and sadness into a single scene.

Where does Harry operate?

Harry primarily operates on the subway, living in the Bronx but finding most of his work in Manhattan.

Given the film’s exploration of a changing New York City, do you think the pace of modern life diminishes opportunities for the kind of personal connections depicted in the story?

The Only Living Pickpocket in New York review – John Turturro steals this simple, charming tale | Sundance 2026