America at 250: The Future of American Democracy
Panelists on a special edition of “Washington Week With The Atlantic” recently analyzed the state of American democracy 250 years after the Declaration of Independence. The discussion focused on the successes and challenges of the American experiment, with staff writer Tim Alberta identifying a current “epistemological crisis” regarding shared facts.
Why is the U.S. facing an “epistemological crisis”?
Tim Alberta, a staff writer at The Atlantic, argued that the United States currently suffers from an “epistemological crisis.” According to Alberta, citizens no longer share a lived reality or operate from a common baseline of information and fact.
Alberta stated that this divide has led people to conclude that no one is looking out for them. He noted that many now believe no one has their best interests in mind and that no one can be trusted.
Who analyzed the state of the American experiment?
Jeffrey Goldberg, the editor in chief of The Atlantic, moderated the discussion. The panel included a group of journalists and writers from various national publications.
Participants included Tim Alberta, Idrees Kahloon, and Ashley Parker from The Atlantic. They were joined by Stephen Hayes, editor of The Dispatch; Peter Baker, chief White House correspondent at The New York Times; and Susan Glasser, a staff writer at The New Yorker.
What may happen to the American experiment?
The ongoing lack of a shared reality could further erode public trust in institutional leadership. If citizens continue to feel that no one is looking out for their interests, the divide in lived realities may likely widen.

Future stability may depend on whether the nation can resolve this epistemological crisis. A possible next step for the American experiment could involve finding ways to re-establish a common baseline of information among the public.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the “epistemological crisis” mentioned in the discussion?
According to Tim Alberta, it is a state where people no longer share a lived reality or operate from a common baseline of fact and information.
Who participated in the “Washington Week With The Atlantic” panel?
The panel was led by Jeffrey Goldberg and included Tim Alberta, Stephen Hayes, Peter Baker, Idrees Kahloon, Susan Glasser, and Ashley Parker.
What was the primary occasion for this discussion?
The panelists met to discuss the state of democracy and the American experiment 250 years after the Declaration of Independence.
Do you believe a common baseline of fact is necessary for a functioning democracy?